Pick | Team | Mel Kiper 2.0 | Todd McShay 2.0 | Website Consensus |
 1 |  | Trevor Lawrence QB Clemson | Trevor Lawrence QB Clemson | Trevor Lawrence QB Clemson Grade:97 |
 2 |  | Zach Wilson QB BYUTrade | Zach Wilson QB BYU | Zach Wilson QB BYU Grade:92 |
 3 |  | DeVonta Smith WR Alabama | Trey Lance QB North Dakota StateTrade | DeVonta Smith WR Alabama Grade:93 |
 4 |  | Kyle Pitts TE Florida | Justin Fields QB Ohio State | Justin Fields QB Ohio State Grade:91 |
 5 |  | Penei Sewell OT Oregon | Penei Sewell OT Oregon | Penei Sewell OT Oregon Grade:93 |
 6 |  | Ja'Marr Chase WR LSU | Ja'Marr Chase WR LSU | Ja'Marr Chase WR LSU Grade:92 |
 7 |  | Justin Fields QB Ohio StateTrade | DeVonta Smith WR Alabama | Mac Jones QB Alabama Grade:90 |
 8 |  | Mac Jones QB Alabama | Jaylen Waddle WR AlabamaTrade | Micah Parsons ILB Penn State Grade:93 |
 9 |  | Trey Lance QB North Dakota StateTrade | Patrick Surtain II CB Alabama | Patrick Surtain II CB Alabama Grade:92 |
 10 |  | Patrick Surtain II CB Alabama | Caleb Farley CB Virginia Tech | Caleb Farley CB Virginia Tech Grade:90 |
 11 |  | Jaylen Waddle WR Alabama | Kyle Pitts TE Florida | Kyle Pitts TE Florida Grade:92 |
 12 |  | Micah Parsons ILB Penn State | Mac Jones QB AlabamaTrade | Jeremiah Owusu-Koramoah ILB Notre Dame Grade:91 |
 13 |  | Rashawn Slater C Northwestern | Rashawn Slater C Northwestern | Christian Darrisaw OT Virginia Tech Grade:90 |
 14 |  | Alijah Vera-Tucker OG USC | Alijah Vera-Tucker OG USC | Alijah Vera-Tucker OG USC Grade:89 |
 15 |  | Caleb Farley CB Virginia Tech | Micah Parsons ILB Penn State | Jamie Newman QB Georgia Grade:73 |
 16 |  | Jaycee Horn CB South Carolina | Gregory Rousseau DE Miami | Rashawn Slater C Northwestern Grade:91 |
 17 |  | Trevon Moehrig S TCU | Jeremiah Owusu-Koramoah ILB Notre Dame | Trevon Moehrig S TCU Grade:91 |
 18 |  | Jeremiah Owusu-Koramoah ILB Notre Dame | Jaelan Phillips DE Miami | Jaelan Phillips DE Miami Grade:90 |
 19 |  | Christian Darrisaw OT Virginia Tech | Kadarius Toney WR Florida | Travis Etienne RB Clemson Grade:89 |
 20 |  | Kadarius Toney WR Florida | Trevon Moehrig S TCU | Kadarius Toney WR Florida Grade:90 |
 21 |  | Gregory Rousseau DE Miami | Kwity Paye DE Michigan | Kwity Paye DE Michigan Grade:89 |
 22 |  | Jaelan Phillips DE Miami | Azeez Ojulari OLB Georgia | Joe Tryon DE Washington Grade:90 |
 23 |  | Kwity Paye DE Michigan | Travis Etienne RB Clemson | Najee Harris RB Alabama Grade:90 |
 24 |  | Landon Dickerson C Alabama | Christian Darrisaw OT Virginia Tech | Levi Onwuzurike DT Washington Grade:89 |
 25 |  | Christian Barmore DT Alabama | Levi Onwuzurike DT Washington | Christian Barmore DT Alabama Grade:90 |
 26 |  | Zaven Collins OLB Tulsa | Zaven Collins OLB Tulsa | Zaven Collins OLB Tulsa Grade:90 |
 27 |  | Terrace Marshall Jr. WR LSU | Jaycee Horn CB South Carolina | Jaycee Horn CB South Carolina Grade:89 |
 28 |  | Jayson Oweh DE Penn St | Jalen Mayfield OT Michigan | Jayson Oweh DE Penn St Grade:87 |
 29 |  | Joe Tryon DE Washington | Aaron Robinson CB UCF | Elijah Moore WR Ole Miss Grade:88 |
 30 |  | Teven Jenkins OT Oklahoma State | Najee Harris RB Alabama | Teven Jenkins OT Oklahoma State Grade:88 |
 31 |  | Walker Little OT Stanford | Joe Tryon DE Washington | Terrace Marshall Jr. WR LSU Grade:88 |
 32 |  | Azeez Ojulari OLB Georgia | Christian Barmore DT Alabama | Azeez Ojulari OLB Georgia Grade:88 |