| Pick | Team | Mel Kiper 1.0 | Todd McShay 2.0 | Website
Consensus |
| 1 |  | Bryce Young
QB Alabama | Bryce Young
QB Alabama | Bryce Young
QB Alabama Grade:95 |
| 2 |  | C.J. Stroud
QB Ohio State | C.J. Stroud
QB Ohio State | C.J. Stroud
QB Ohio State Grade:93 |
| 3 |  | Will Anderson Jr.
OLB Alabama | Will Anderson Jr.
OLB Alabama | Will Anderson Jr.
OLB Alabama Grade:95 |
| 4 |  | Jalen Carter
DT Georgia | Anthony Richardson
QB Florida | Anthony Richardson
QB Florida Grade:89 |
| 5 |  | Will Levis
QB KentuckyTrade | Tyree Wilson
DE Texas Tech | Tyree Wilson
DE Texas Tech Grade:93 |
| 6 |  | Christian Gonzalez
CB Oregon | Christian Gonzalez
CB Oregon | Christian Gonzalez
CB Oregon Grade:93 |
| 7 |  | Devon Witherspoon
CB Illinois | Will Levis
QB Kentucky | Will Levis
QB Kentucky Grade:91 |
| 8 |  | Will McDonald IV
DE Iowa State | Nolan Smith
OLB Georgia | Devon Witherspoon
CB Illinois Grade:91 |
| 9 |  | Anthony Richardson
QB FloridaTrade | Peter Skoronski
OT Northwestern | Michael Mayer
TE Notre Dame Grade:92 |
| 10 |  | Peter Skoronski
OT Northwestern | Bijan Robinson
RB Texas | Bijan Robinson
RB Texas Grade:93 |
| 11 |  | Paris Johnson Jr.
OT Ohio State | Paris Johnson Jr.
OT Ohio State | Paris Johnson Jr.
OT Ohio State Grade:92 |
| 12 | | Tyree Wilson
DE Texas Tech | Jalen Carter
DT Georgia | Broderick Jones
OT Georgia Grade:89 |
| 13 |  | Anton Harrison
OT Oklahoma | Broderick Jones
OT Georgia | Nolan Smith
OLB Georgia Grade:92 |
| 14 |  | Jaxon Smith-Njigba
WR Ohio State | Quentin Johnston
WR TCU | Quentin Johnston
WR TCU Grade:92 |
| 15 |  | Michael Mayer
TE Notre Dame | Michael Mayer
TE Notre Dame | Jordan Addison
WR USC Grade:91 |
| 16 |  | Darnell Wright
OT Tennessee | Devon Witherspoon
CB Illinois | Darnell Wright
OT Tennessee Grade:89 |
| 17 |  | Joey Porter Jr.
CB Penn State | Emmanuel Forbes
CB Mississippi State | Joey Porter Jr.
CB Penn State Grade:90 |
| 18 | | Drew Sanders
ILB Arkansas | Lukas Van Ness
DE Iowa | Drew Sanders
ILB Arkansas Grade:85 |
| 19 |  | Emmanuel Forbes
CB Mississippi State | Joey Porter Jr.
CB Penn State | Emmanuel Forbes
CB Mississippi State Grade:91 |
| 20 | | Myles Murphy
DE Clemson | Myles Murphy
DE Clemson | Myles Murphy
DE Clemson Grade:91 |
| 21 |  | | | |
| 22 |  | Jordan Addison
WR USC | Jordan Addison
WR USC | Calijah Kancey
DT Pittsburgh Grade:87 |
| 23 |  | Zay Flowers
WR Boston College | Jaxon Smith-Njigba
WR Ohio State | Zay Flowers
WR Boston College Grade:89 |
| 24 |  | Deonte Banks
CB Maryland | Deonte Banks
CB Maryland | Deonte Banks
CB Maryland Grade:89 |
| 25 |  | Lukas Van Ness
DE Iowa | Darnell Wright
OT Tennessee | Lukas Van Ness
DE Iowa Grade:92 |
| 26 |  | Quentin Johnston
WR TCU | Zay Flowers
WR Boston College | Jordan Addison
WR USC Grade:91 |
| 27 |  | Dalton Kincaid
TE Utah | Dalton Kincaid
TE Utah | Dalton Kincaid
TE Utah Grade:90 |
| 28 |  | Bijan Robinson
RB Texas | Keion White
OLB Georgia Tech | Keion White
OLB Georgia Tech Grade:90 |
| 29 |  | Luke Musgrave
TE Oregon State | Anton Harrison
OT Oklahoma | Luke Musgrave
TE Oregon State Grade:85 |
| 30 |  | Darnell Washington
TE Georgia | Bryan Bresee
DT Clemson | Bryan Bresee
DT Clemson Grade:89 |
| 31 | | Calijah Kancey
DT Pittsburgh | Calijah Kancey
DT Pittsburgh | Antonio Johnson
S Texas A&M Grade:86 |
| 32 |  | Broderick Jones
OT Georgia | Derick Hall
DE Auburn | Derick Hall
DE Auburn Grade:87 |